Monday, July 6, 2009

Quickie Reviews of ClamXav, iAntiVirus and MacScan

--
Recently, I've been testing the free anti-malware options for Mac. At the moment, none of them are perfect. But there is progress! Below are posts I made this week over at the VersionTracker.com sites regarding iAntiVirus, ClamXav and MacScan:

I) MacScan Is Unreliable:
I've tested MacScan several times over the course of several versions. The results are consistently flaky. It is impossible to get it to detect items reliably. Instead you have to run it over and over and over and over to get the thing to pick up everything.

For some purposes, like detecting the full raft of 'legal' Mac Spyware and Tracking Cookies, this is the only show in town. But OMG does it suck. IMHO MacScan requires an entire rewrite in order get a rating better than one star. The developers have done some nice things like providing some sort-of working removal tools for current Trojans. So they aren't evil. They're just lousy programmers.
II) iAntiVirus Is Basic, Not Perfect, Mostly Works:
Keep in mind that this thing is FREE:

Despite some outright dishonest flame reviews of iAntiVirus here at VT, it actually does work, mostly. I let it loose on a folder full of Trojans a friend shared with me and it successfully found MOST of them:

Trojan.OSX.RSPlug.C, D & F
Trojan.OSX.iServices.A & B

Problems:
1) It did NOT find Trojan.OSX.RSPlug.E, of which I had a number of copies in my folder-full-of-Trojans. That is upsetting.
2) It also uses wrong names for the iServices Trojans. But sadly, despite a clear naming convention for malware, hardly anyone bothers, which is of course pathetic.
3) The app only gives you two choices when it finds malware: Either remove the malware or nothing. There is no sophistication to this app whatsoever.

Maybe the 'Pro' version is way better. I don't know. The PC Tools website certainly 'claims' iAntiVirus detects all the current Mac malware. Judging from the free version, it only finds some Mac malware. Maybe I'll test the Pro version some time.

In the meantime, I own Intego VirusBarrier, which frankly is the ONLY anti-malware app for Macs I can recommend. It works great, detects everything, is updated daily, is entirely reliable, is never a CPU hog, and has all the bells and whistles you could want.

If you want to stick with free stuff, the best idea is to use BOTH iAntiVirus AND ClamXav. Between the two of them you're probably just fine. This is thanks to the fact that the excellent author of ClamXav went out of his way to convince the ClamAV project to accept contemporary Mac malware sample definitions. *Applause*
Addendum: I should note that iAntiVirus also fails to detect RSPlug.I and .L.

III) ClamXav: Progress! But Still Waiting For Full Mac Malware Detection:
Recently, ClamXav developer Mark Allen went out of his way to convince the ClamAV project to accept contemporary Mac malware samples for definition integration. *Applause*

However, my testing today shows only partial progress from the ClamAV project.

MY TEST: A friend provided me with a large collection of recent Mac Trojan horses including all the iServices and RSPlug malware. There were 18 samples in all. I used them as my testing ground.

RESULTS: ClamXav, via the latest engine and definitions of ClamAV, found 10 of them and successfully put them into my quarantine folder.

As my control, I used Intego VirusBarrier, latest version with current definitions. It found all but one of the malware. (The undetected malware was a .pkg with the payload inside a .bom file).

What ClamXav, via ClamAV, didn't detect:
DMG files containing:
RSPlug.D
RSPlug.E
RSPlug.F
RSPlug.I
RSPlug.L

I'm testing iAntiVirus, (runs on Mac OS X Leopard only). But it too is unable to detect RSPlug.E [as well as .I and .L].

CONCLUSIONS:

1) ClamXav is the best of the free anti-malware application options. But the ClamAV database of current Mac malware is still not completely up to date. However, it is far better than it was a couple months ago thanks to Mark Allen's work.

2) Even with the combination of ClamXav and iAntiVirus, it is still possible to have a current Mac Trojan sneak by. But then again, Intego VirusBarrier missed one as well, possibly due to the way the Trojan was packaged.

A high quality paid anti-malware application remains the best way to go for professional use. But for casual use, ClamXav is the best, despite remaining ClamAV deficiencies. I would combine it with iAntiVirus as well if you are running Mac OS X Leopard.
--

Wednesday, June 24, 2009

Adobe Shockwave Player v11.5.0.600 & Apple vs. Java Insecurity

--
In its recent attempt to get serious about application security, last week Adobe released Shockwave Player v11.5.0.600 for Mac. Oddly, they released the Windows version a week later. I say oddly because Mac versions of Adobe software are almost always late. It's amusing to see a swap for a change. Now if only Adobe would release the many years delayed 64 bit versions of their applications. Hint hint Adobe.

MacWorld messed up today (6/24) and reported that the Adobe security bulletin about the Windows version 11.5.0.600 of Shockwave Player had anything to do with the Mac version. So I posted a reply comment, which you'll find below. After I posted my comment I visited the Adobe site to find any news about the Mac version. There isn't any. I did however learn that Shockwave Player is compatible with Mac OS X Tiger. That's good to know. I dug around in the installer package and found nothing there as well. If you find anything relevant to Mac security improvements in Shockwave Player v11.5.0.600, please leave a comment.

Here is my comment to MacWorld regarding Adobe Shockwave Player. It is also relevant to Apple's slow poke response to Java security problems:

A couple points:

1) The Adobe Security Bulletin (it's not a blog) is specific to the Windows version ONLY, which apparently was just finished and released. The Mac version of Adobe Shockwave Player v11.5.0.600 was released a week ago on June 16th. Adobe didn't post a security bulletin for the Mac version. And that means what?!

2) bousozoku sez: "Adobe seems to be the only company slower than Apple at taking care of security concerns."

Adobe's attention to security went into deep decline until this past month.

In the meantime, Apple have been improving their attention to security exponentially over the last couple years. It appears to be in response to both the moronic anti-Apple security FUD-fest instigated by Symantec in August 2005, and the White Hat focus on Apple security bugs and vulnerabilities. As is typical with Apple, drag them through the press and they respond.

Where Apple recently fell on their face was with regards to a slew of vulnerabilities in the mess known as Java. Apple were over 6 months behind in Java patches. Sadly, Apple's incredibly slow response to Java updates is consistent. Never has Apple had a serious Java team. Of course one reason is that Apple has to do ALL the work to provide Mac OS X Java updates. Sun provides nothing.

Meanwhile, despite Microsoft's outright hatred of all things Java, to the extent that they were found guilty in court of attempting to destroy Java via their J++ monstrosity, Sun Microsystems write and provide all Windows Java updates. Microsoft never has to lift a finger. That is the single sole reason Windows gets Java updates before Mac OS X. Hey thanks Sun. Sorry you're dead.
--

Friday, May 29, 2009

Microsoft Senior Security Architect Said WHAT?!

Someone needs a good spanking and a time out for bad behavior. He's considered to be a professional computer security expert, (so it's not me!).

This afternoon I was checking out the Intego Mac Security Blog and read about interviews ZDNet Australia had done with security specialists regarding the question "Do Mac Users Need Antivirus Software?" (They got the software category wrong as usual. It's anti-malware, not 'anti-virus'. I'll go down in history as the curmudgeon who chanted this fact to the grave, and nobody cared. Poor me). So I clicked over to ZDNet OZ, read their article and watched the video, found HERE.

In the video, note the fellow in the white shirt with a British accent. That's Greg Singh from RSA. As Intego point out, Singh is incorrect to say Mac users will have to get used to the degradation in performance caused by anti-malware applications. He could be talking specifically about Symantec's Norton Antivirus for Mac, in which case no one could argue with him. He also insinuates that Apple have said Mac OS X is not susceptible to 'viruses'. Oops, I think he got his Apples mixed up. He must have meant Apple Corps, the folks who make Beatles CDs. Yeah, I'd agree that Beatles recordings are not susceptible to viruses. **snicker**

Then there's the guy in the black t-shirt and hat reading 'ULTIMATE-DEFENCE". That's Rocky Heckman from Microsoft. He has the title of "Microsoft Senior Security Architect". I was freaked at what was coming out of his mouth. First he thinks BSD is something new to Mac OS X Tiger. He was born yesterday. Then he says that because BSD is part of Mac OS X, hackers are now realizing they can write 'viruses' for it, "and there have been a couple out there." He's from the Bizarro World. There are no viruses for Mac OS X. There are only Trojans, and he knows the difference. I wrote a ripping comment about Mr. Heckman over at the ZDNet OZ site. See below.

Then there's an Australian fellow in a white striped shirt with a big pad and marker hanging around his neck. I don't know his name, sorry. His odd statement, if you listen carefully, is that anti-malware products for Mac OS X are 'immature'. Based on what information? Based on ignorance. Very strange.

OK, so where were all these incorrect people when they were interviewed? The AusCERT 2009 IT Security Conference. The mind boggles.

Here is the concerned comment I wrote to ZDNet Australia regarding the statements of Mr. Heckman from Microsoft:
Microsoft Senior Security Architect Said WHAT?!

"Microsoft senior security architect Rocky Heckman said AV became necessary when Apple in 2001 decided to underpin OS X Tiger with the BSD operating system because it made Macs an easier platform to write malicious code for."

Why did anyone ask Mr. Heckman his opinion? We certainly have no reason to care. Windows is the single LEAST secure operating system, commercial or Open Source, available on the planet.

Why Heckman's opinion is lunatic:

1) Apple didn't decide to underpin Tiger with BSD. NeXT decided to underpin NeXTStep with BSD decades ago! Mac OS X inherited it when Apple decided to make NeXTStep/OpenStep the foundation for Rhapsody, which was then developed into Mac OS X.

2) The three most secure operating systems on the planet have been repeatedly proven to be:
A) OpenBSD
B) FreeBSD
C) Mac OS X
Mac OS X incorporates elements of both OpenBSD and FreeBSD into it's core OS called Darwin OS. So what Mr. Heckman it talking about is incomprehensible. He is either a blithering idiot or is pulling a FUD manoeuvre by telling the opposite of the truth in order to fool the public that black is white, war is peace, hate is love, the usual doublespeak routine from the book '1984'. Shame on Mr. Heckman.

This has to be one of the most dishonest statements from a Microsoft executive of all time. It's running neck-and-neck with Bill Gates' moronic statement that Mac OS X is exploited everyday, when it fact it is HIS operating system that is exploited every day.

Or maybe there's lead in the water over at Redmond. (o_0)
--

Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Hope For ClamAV For Mac

--
As you recall from our last episode, ClamAV was essentially worthless for detecting and removing the current 11 malware for Mac OS X. However, hope appeared last week thanks to the persistence of Mark Allan, the developer of the ClamXav GUI application, and myself.

I wrote a series of posts over at the ClamXav Forum last week that revved up some interest in sorting out the problem with ClamAV. I found out that a number of people, including Mark Allan himself, had submitted MOSX malware to the ClamAV project, using the official protocol, and had been entirely ignored. From my experience, there are a number of plain old dickheads over at the ClamAV project who resist any improvement in MOSX support. You have to wonder what goes on in some people's heads.

However, Mark Allan and I chatted about the situation and he was inspired to try once again to contact someone sane over at the ClamAV group. And he SUCCEEDED. I could not be more pleased.

Mark is now working with the ClamAV project to provide them with Mac OS X malware. The resulting malware definitions will then be integrated into ClamAV. If this relationship works out, and Mark is able to continue his freely given dedication to Mac OS X security, we should soon see and continue to see ClamAV as a free useful tool for Mac OS X users.

You can read about and download ClamXav, Mark Allan's free Mac OS X GUI version of ClamAV, HERE. Donations are welcome. You can join in on the ClamXav Forum discussions THERE.
--

Thursday, May 21, 2009

Java is DANGER! Apple is SLOW POKE!

--
One of my favorite jabs at the anti-Mac security FUD mongers is to point out that their FUD attack party, ongoing since it was started by Symantec way back in August 2005, has happily prodded Apple to get serious about Mac OS X security updates. I then extend them a hearty handshake and gleefully, maniacally, laugh.

However, Mac security mavens point out that Apple is still a slow poke. Damned right! There are a couple short articles over at Intego about an ongoing security hole in the current implementation of Java in Mac OS X:
-> Apple Hasn’t Updated Java to Protect Mac Users from Critical Vulnerabilities
-> Intego Security Memo: Java Vulnerability

To defenders of the faith, such as myself, this is annoying. First off, we get to be poked by the FUD mongers with the 'see, I told you' routine. Second off, I am so sick of the corrosion that has happened to the great and shiny image in the sky of Java being this ultra-safe, can't break into your computer, can't hurt you, technology. Yeah, and Sun is now no more. Justice is served. But we're stuck with the mess as a web standard.
*rolling eyes*
--

Twitter Spamrat Attacks -> Nuisance

--
Last night I became aware that someone has, dare I say, 'hacked' Twitter such that logged in users are instantaneously befriended/followed by scum spammers. For all I know, this is deliberate by the Twitter folks or there is some other nebulous explanation. What I do know is that it is a BLOODY NUISANCE!

Thankfully it is easy to block the spamrats as they show up in your followers list. But then you have to scour through your followers list at least every day to kick them out. So far it is also easy to spot them by checking out their page. It will be full of moronic spam tweets. If by chance you've been vacant enough to choose to follow them and your tweet collection turns into a pile of blithering idiotic ads for rubbish, again it is easy to kick them.

I hope Twitter get a handle on this, if indeed it isn't some sort of sell-out collaboration, because it is soooo boring having to sort through your lists and play Spot-The-Loony. Bloody! Bloody I say!
:-Q********
--

Sunday, May 17, 2009

Current List of Mac OS X Active Malware

--
This evening I was busy over at the ClamXav forum. In response to a suggestion there, I provided a current list of Mac OS X active malware. I decided to cross-post the list here as well:

Below is a list of all the Mac OS X active malware I am aware of. I've been attempting to keep up to date on this subject since 2005. I have a blog where I share all my knowledge of Mac security:

http://mac-security.blogspot.com

As far as I am able to ascertain, the only active Mac OS X malware ClamAV is able to detect is Trojan.OSX.RSPlug.A (aka DNSChanger.A). In a previous thread I have asked for help trying to determine if any further Mac OS X malware are detected.

Note that there is only one official standard name for each of the 11 malware. This is what I use to name each family. However, anti-malware providers call them anything they choose. This is why I provide alternative names. There are four families of Trojans listed below with various strains/versions/variants designated by "A" through however many exist for the family. In the case of RSPlug I list A through G specifically because the PCTools site lists that many. Most other sites list only A through F.

If anyone knows of further names for these malware, or of any further ACTIVE malware (please not inert or proof-of-concept malware) please let me know at my blog.

The current list of active Mac OS X malware as of 2009-05-17:

I) Trojan.OSX.RSPlug family, aka DNSChanger or Jahlav.
01) Trojan.OSX.RSPlug.A
02) Trojan.OSX.RSPlug.B
03) Trojan.OSX.RSPlug.C
04) Trojan.OSX.RSPlug.D
05) Trojan.OSX.RSPlug.E
06) Trojan.OSX.RSPlug.F
07) Trojan.OSX.RSPlug.G

II) Trojan.OSX.Lamzev family, aka Malez.
08) Trojan.OSX.Lamzev.A

III) Trojan.OSX.PokerStealer family, aka Corpref.
09) Trojan.OSX.PokerStealer.A

IV) Trojan.OSX.iServices family.
10) Trojan.OSX.iServices.A
11) Trojan.OSX.iServices.B

Sources of these malware:

The RSPlug family are all offered by websites that tell you that you must install their file or program in order to access specific media they are offering. Originally these Trojans showed up on porn sites where you were told to download a video codec in order to view their videos. These days the websites could be telling you anything. The basic idea is to use 'Social Engineering' to fool you into installing their Trojan. The most recent of these Trojans can potentially zombie your computer and use it in a botnet.

Lamzev is a hacker tool used to create backdoor access into a computer. The only way to 'catch' it is if a hacker has physical access to your computer and hand-installs it. Note that there are plenty of other hacker tools around, but this is the only one listed as a Trojan because of the potential damage it can do to a victim computer.

PokerStealer originally called itself "PokerGame". You download it, install it and are infected. The original version put up a bogus warning message that a corrupt preference file had been detected and that your administrative password was required to repair it. It then sends your ID, password and IP address to crackers who can then access your computer via SSH and do whatever they like with it. Theoretically this Trojan can be named anything.

iServices showed up earlier this year in pirated programs, buried inside their installer. The original A and B variants were buried in pirated versions of iWorks 09 and Photoshop CS4. You install the pirated program and get infected. There are reports that the installers actually fail to install the listed program and only install the Trojan. In any case, iServices zombies your computer and makes it part of a botnet. This Trojan formed the first officially verified Mac botnet back in February. It apparently consists of thousands of computers. It has so far been used in a DDOS attack. Note that once a Mac is zombied, the 'bot wranger' or cracker-in-charge can do anything they like with the computer. This particular zombie botnet is so far is being used for money making ventures over the Internet.

If/when further Mac OS X active malware is discovered I'll list it in my blog.
--